Fighting the War on Error

"You measure a democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists."
- Political & Social Activist Abbie Hoffman (1936-1989)

Monday, August 07, 2006

Next must-see movie - The War Tapes



This one is going to be one helluva ride. The War Tapes is a movie about five soldiers from a New Hampshire National Guard unit - C Company, 3rd of the 172nd Mountain Infantry - who taped their experiences in Iraq. To be up front, it's not a political movie, so far as I can see.

I listened to a Podcast interview the other day with the director of the movie, Deborah Scranton, and she had this to say:

"I wanted to really get to as close to the experience of war as possible; to climb inside and feel it all around," said Scranton. "The comments that we're getting is that the level of authenticity has never before been seen."

Scranton maintains that it's not a political documentary/movie - there are some political beliefs in the film spoken by some of the soldiers, but the movie is not made from the persepective of being pro-war or anti-war. That's Scranton's position, but viewers will have to decide.

However, Staff Sergeant Zack Bazzi, one of the soldiers who shot footage for the documentary, agrees with her on that count, saying, "I think she has succeeded in making a non-political film about the war."

Bazzi had some pretty powerful things to say about the movie and the war in this same Podcast.

"I do believe that Americans should know what war is like," said Bazzi. "I don't care if you are for the war or against the war. The fact is, you can't take a position on something you do not understand. And if that [the footage] happens to be gruesome, tough luck. [The war] is being done in your name as a country. I think it's a moral and political responsibility to [see the effects of war]."

I have no way in knowing, but it's my guess that most Americans have no idea about the cost of this war. Maybe in financial terms, yes (and it's quickly running into the hundreds of billions of dollars). But, in terms of death, mayhem and destruction, both on U.S. soldiers and the citizens of Iraq, no.

Many on the right paint dissenters about the war as unpatriotic, un-American or "sympathisizing with the terrorists." I have nothing but a giant fuck you for people of this ilk, but also something slightly more intelligent to say: You don't understand America.

Wasn't it Thomas Jefferson who said, "Dissent is the highest form of patriotism"?

Often when I criticize Bush, (and that's often) especially in the presence of right-wingers, I get this doozy - "If you don't like America, leave!" So, that's what we've come to? A half-baked witticism (and that's being kind) when you hear a political belief you don't happen to agree with? Now, people should leave the country if they disagree? Puleeze. My own half-baked response to those people? If you love Bush's war so much, what are you still doing here? Shut up and ship out.

Anyway, I think this is an important film, and I'm not alone. Here's a few quotes from the movie's Web site:

"Riveting! Compelling!... Gives a stronger taste of the Iraq war experience than any film I can remember."- Stephen Holden, The New York Times

“The first indispensable Iraq documentary.”- Owen Gleiberman, Entertainment Weekly

"Remarkable. Very moving. Very real."- Mark Bowden, author of Black Hawk Down

"The single best document (book, film or article) you could see" on the war in Iraq - John Fisher Burns, the New York Times' Baghdad bureau chief and two-time Pulitzer Prize winning foreign correspondent

##

Not bad words, coming from the author of Black Hawk Down and the New York Times' Baghdad bureau chief.

This movie is a must see. As usual about movies I write about here, I'll review it when I see it.

The War Tapes opens August 9th.

Labels: , , , , ,

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for the post on our film. We depend on word of mouth and appreciate your post. I did want to point out though, that the film follows soldiers from a New Hampshire National Guard unit -- C Company, 3rd of the 172nd Mountain Infantry and not Marines. Thanks.

Mon Aug 07, 09:49:00 AM PDT  
Blogger RJ said...

Thanks so much for your comments, Deborah. I've made the correction, and I can't wait to see your film!

~RJ

Tue Aug 08, 05:14:00 AM PDT  

Post a Comment

<< Home