Ellen presses McCain on gay marriage
I have to tip my hat to Ellen DeGeneres, who had John McCain on her talk show the other day to discuss some issues. She courageously stood up to McCain about an issue that's obviously important to her - gay marriage. A partial transcript:
McCain said, "I think that people should be able to enter into legal agreements and it's something that we should encourage, particularly in the case of insurance and other areas and decisions that have to be made. I just believe in the unique status of marriage between a man and a woman and I know that we have a respectful disagreement on that issue."Of course, this is another example of a McCain flip-flop (which is again getting zero press). Cliff Schecter has plenty more on McCain's "refinement" on gay marriage:
Ellen responded, "I think that it is looked at and some people are saying the same that blacks and women did not have the right to vote. Women just got the right to vote in 1920. Blacks didn't have the right to vote until 1870 and it just feels like there's this old way of thinking that we are not all the same. We are all the same people. All of us. You are no different than I am. Our love is the same. To me, what it feels like, I will just speak for myself, it feels like when someone says, 'You can still have a contract and you'll still have insurance and you'll get all that' — it sounds like you can sit there, but you can't sit there. That's what is sounds like to me."
The problem is that McCain himself not only supported an amendment to the Arizona Constitution in 2006 that would have banned any "legal agreements" including "insurance" for domestic partners, but he cut advertisements for the measure (which failed). He also told prominent campaign supporter the late Jerry Falwell--who blamed 9/11 on gays and lesbians, among others--that if state constitutional measures such as this one were struck down by the courts, he would then support a federal gay-marriage ban.The book The Real McCain, (written by Schecter) which I'm now reading, has more on this issue, and when I'm done with the book, I'll share more of my thoughts on McCain and gay marriage.
Good for Ellen for standing up for what she believes in to a nominee for President of the United States.
Shame on McCain, for again misleading the American people about his past position(s) on this issue. Of course, he counts on the fact that so few people will actually do the legwork and discover what those past positions are, he just spews forth lie after lie after lie, while our corporate media yawns.
h/t Crooks & Liars
Labels: Ellen DeGeneres, Gay Marriage, John McCain







2 Comments:
i love ellen
http://www.queersunited.blogspot.com
I like Ellen a lot, I would love to meet her. I also think Ellen did make a compelling argument.
Here is the problem. What Ellen is asking for is for the state to go beyond just declaring legal partnerships and declare gay unions as having the sacred status of “marriage”.
Now this is not to say that there can’t be compelling arguments for why gay unions could not be considered sacred and given the term marriage; I am just not sure that government is really able to mandate any union beyond just it’s legality and declare something “sacred” one way or the other. So perhaps government has over stepped its boundaries by ever declaring any legal union, even heterosexual, a marriage.
Perhaps the answer is for government to get out of the marriage game all together and declare both homosexual and heterosexual unions “civil unions” and let marriage be determined in the context of peoples various religious and cultural communities.
This way everyone would have the same legal rights and at the same time allow diverse communities to determine on their own what would constitute sacred and marriage beyond just a legal agreement and partnership; and no one could deny them that.
Just a thought, I would love to hear your opinion.
Peace,
James
Post a Comment
<< Home