Fighting the War on Error

"You measure a democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists."
- Political & Social Activist Abbie Hoffman (1936-1989)

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Huffington & Ham discuss blog hate speech



I've got so much to try to get to tonight, but I had to quickly share this piece of footage. I love Arianna Huffington, and I even liked her when she was a conservative. Her sketches with Al Franken on Bill Maher's Politically Incorrect during the 1996 election were very funny and cool.

Her Website, The Huffington Post, (or HuffPo, as I refer to it) is a click I make every day when catching up on the latest political news.

Huffington recently appeared on Howard Kutz's CNN show Reliable Sources to talk about free speech and hate speech in the blogosphere, and conservative Mary Katherine Ham was also on the show.

It's amazing to me how Ham tries to politicize hate speech on blogs. Her Ham-handed attempt to paint Huffington with the well-worn brush from the conservative arsenal - being a purveyor of hate speech against this administration - falls flat. I guess when it comes to hate speech, familiarity breeds contempt, especially considering Ham's history with Michelle Malkin. Anyone doubting Malkin's intolerance credentials, click Here.

Ham tried to call out Arianna for some comments that were left on her site following Vice President Cheney's close call over in Afghanistan, when the front gate of a Marine compound he was staying at was attacked by a suicide bomber. A few morons on Huffington's site posted some ridiculous comments, expressing regret that Cheney was unharmed in the incident.

Of course, right-wingers went nuts, claiming that Huffington waited too long to take the comments down, etc. In the video above, Ham tries to make hay of it again.

Arianna was right to come right back over the top of Ham, who insinuates here that Huffington supported such speech, or the idea behind it. Lots of morons leave absurd messages on both sides of the political spectrum - no ideology or political viewpoint is exempt. Ham's whining about Malkin is also a kick - maybe if Malkin weren't so insanely intolerant, she wouldn't be such a lightning rod for nasty comments. I'm not defending people who call her the "C-word," but she brings a lot of detractors on herself. If you don't believe me, cruise on over to her Website and see for yourself. I think Malkin and Ann Coulter were separated at birth.

Where Huffington really makes sense here is when she refers to Websites' content; it IS absurd for people like Ham to try and paint liberals or people who read liberal blogs as "monkeys hanging from the rafters" when she's in the corner of the likes of Malkin and Coulter.

If you go by content, people like Malkin and Coulter lead the way in hate speech. When Huffington mentions this, Ham predictably swallows her tongue.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Alex Bennett, allow me to introduce you to the First Amendment

I occasionally listen to Alex Bennett on Sirius Left, but this morning the liberal commentator was over the top, even for him. He started out by saying that Scooter Libby should be set free.

Really? That's completely absurd, but I'll have more on that in a separate post in a minute.

What annoyed me even more than Bennett's Libby comments, though, was his take on Ann Coulter. Yesterday, three newspapers, The Oakland Press in Michigan, The Mountain Press in Tennessee and The Lancaster New Era in Lancaster, Pa. announced they were dropping Ann Coulter's column.

Bennett went on to say that "I'm not going to defend Ann Coulter's comment, but I'll defend her right to say it." Fair enough, and I agree with that point. Hold on, though.

He then proceeded to question the newspapers' veracity in removing Coulter's column from their pages. That's ridiculous and absurd.

Yes, we live in a free country with a free press, and Coulter has the right to spew her tripe, but the media is under no obligation to publish or disseminate her tripe. The media's refusal to do so is not censorship!

Bennett reasoned the papers were wrong by no longer publishing her column, using "freedom of the press" as a justification for his reasoning.

By that rationale, why isn't David Duke's column running The New York Times? (If, in fact, the bigot has one.) Papers and media outlets can and should have editorial standards. The three papers above, while minor, decided that Coulter's speech and beliefs weren't aligned with their own.

Coulter has plenty of other avenues to get out her messages of hate, including her Website.

Bennett doesn't understand freedom, democracy or the First Amendment.

What annoys me most of all is that this whole brouhaha is precisely what Coulter wants. Every time she says something stupid like this, her book sales go through the roof, and she laughs all the way to the bank.

The next time she writes a book, there will be plenty of conservatives who will ogle her, snatch up her book at $24.95 a pop, and babble, "You're right, John Edwards IS a faggot!"

Pathetic and sad.

Labels: , , , , ,

More Coulter with a side of Maher...

...then I'm taking it off the menu. I'm so tired of hearing about all of this. With all of the serious things we have happening in Washington right now, people are focusing on Ann Coulter and Bill Maher? ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

Hey, I'm guilty, too; I weighed in with my thoughts following Coulter's remarks, but the media, after a slow start in reporting on this story, has gone all Anna Nicole on this story.

For starters, I'm not against Coulter having the ability to be a bigot. Our Constitution makes provisions for hateful, lonely people like Ann. We may not like it, but we have to live with it.

But, Coulter's "faggot" comment about Democratic presidential candidate is only her greatest example of hate, intolerance and downright stupidity.

Following the September 11 attacks, Coulter wrote in a column for the National Review that "we should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity."

A public outcry ensued, but Richard Lowry, her editor at National Review, stuck by her, but not for long. The following week, she pressed ahead with her attack, as outlined in a recent story in The Washington Monthly: "Congress could pass a law tomorrow requiring that all aliens from Arabic countries leave...We should require passports to fly domestically. Passports can be forged, but they can also be checked with the home country in case of any suspicious-looking swarthy males."

Lowry refused to run her column, and Coulter responded as only Coulter knows how when confronted with calm reasoning: she called Lowry and his editorial staff "girly boys" for refusing to run her column. National Review gave her the gate.

What annoys me most about Coulter is that whenever she makes one of her well-publicized idiotic remarks, many Republicans run for cover, hiding behind the well-worn curtain of "She's not mainstream; not many people listen to her."

Funny then, how all of her books have made The New York Times Best Seller List. In short, she's become a millionaire author by people's appetite for her hatred, intolerance and slander. Hardly the makings of a marginalized radical.

Even more damning - she wins awards and is treated with fawning enthusiasm by Republican politicians and organizations. According to The Washington Monthly, last year, the Media Research Center bestowed Coulter with its "Conservative Journalist of the Year" award, and the Clare Boothe Luce Policy Institute conferred upon her its Conservative Leadership Award "for her unfailing dedication to truth, freedom and conservative values and for being an exemplar, in word and deed, of what a true leader is."

Again, marginalized or out-of-the-mainstream she surely is not.

Coulter has a long history of making hateful, jingoistic remarks. Take a quick read of this list, compiled by The Washington Monthly:

"[Clinton] masturbates in the sinks."--Rivera Live, 8/2/99

"God gave us the earth. We have dominion over the plants, the animals, the trees. God
said, 'Earth is yours. Take it. Rape it. It's yours.'"--Hannity & Colmes, 6/20/01

The "backbone of the Democratic Party" is a "typical fat, implacable welfare recipient"--syndicated column, 10/29/99

To a disabled Vietnam vet: "People like you caused us to lose that war."--MSNBC

"Women like Pamela Harriman and Patricia Duff are basically Anna Nicole Smith from the waist down. Let's just call it for what it is. They're whores."--Salon.com, 11/16/00

On Princess Diana's death: "Her children knew she's sleeping with all these men. That just seems to me, it's the definition of 'not a good mother.' ... Is everyone just saying here that it's okay to ostentatiously have premarital sex in front of your children?"..."[Diana is] an ordinary and pathetic and confessional - I've never had bulimia! I've never had an affair! I've never had a divorce! So I don't think she's better than I am."--MSNBC, 9/12/97
That last comment bears closer scrutiny - at 45 years old, time's running out, sweetheart. While I have no problem with women remaining single until whatever age (life doesn't come with a script), it wouldn't be much of a stretch to think that maybe she has a problem attracting anyone with so much hate and bitterness. And as a single mother, Coulter has little ground to stand on to criticize Princess Diana. If there are any princes chasing you down, Ann, produce one of them.

On with the list...

"I think there should be a literacy test and a poll tax for people to vote."--Hannity & Colmes, 8/17/99

"I think [women] should be armed but should not [be allowed to] vote."--Politically Incorrect, 2/26/01

"If you don't hate Clinton and the people who labored to keep him in office, you don't love your country."--George, 7/99

"We're now at the point that it's beyond whether or not this guy is a horny hick. I really think it's a question of his mental stability. He really could be a lunatic. I think it is a rational question for Americans to ask whether their president is insane."--Equal Time

"It's enough [to be impeached] for the president to be a pervert."--The Case Against Bill Clinton, Coulter's 1998 book.

"I think we had enough laws about the turn-of-the-century. We don't need any more." Asked how far back would she go to repeal laws, she replied, "Well, before the New Deal...[The Emancipation Proclamation] would be a good start."--Politically Incorrect, 5/7/97

"I am emboldened by my looks to say things Republican men wouldn't."--TV Guide, 8/97

"Anorexics never have boyfriends. ... That's one way to know you don't have anorexia, if you have a boyfriend."--Politically Incorrect, 7/21/97

"I think [Whitewater]'s going to prevent the First Lady from running for Senate."--Rivera Live, 3/12/99

"My track record is pretty good on predictions."--Rivera Live, 12/8/98

"The thing I like about Bush is I think he hates liberals."--Washington Post, 8/1/00

"The swing voters---I like to refer to them as the idiot voters because they don't have set philosophical principles. You're either a liberal or you're a conservative if you have an IQ above a toaster. "--Beyond the News, Fox News Channel, 6/4/00

"You want to be careful not to become just a blowhard."--Washington Post, 10/16/98

Honestly, I don't really know why, but I've been doing a fair amount of writing on the Coulter dust up, and I don't think I can put it any better than a March 2 column by Jeff Greenwald from Salon.com:

The Conference attendees who will say that they do not approve of Coulter's "joke" will act as though they found her behavior unexpected or surprising -- just as they did last year and every other time she has made similar comments. But three weeks ago, Coulter was on Fox and made virtually identical remarks -- not about Edwards specifically, just the hilarious complaint that people who say the word "faggot" have to enter rehab.

No right-wing supporter (that I know of) complained when they learned that Coulter would be a featured speaker at this event. No prominent "conservative" (that I know of) refused to be a part of the event because Coulter was a featured speaker. Thus, any claims to find what she said so deeply offensive should be weighed against their much more meaningful actions in attending.

Andrew Sullivan [former editor of The New Republic] was (I believe) present at this event, and said this about Coulter's speech:

When you see her in such a context, you realize that she truly represents the heart and soul of contemporary conservative activism, especially among the young. The standing ovation for Romney was nothing like the eruption of enthusiasm that greeted her....

Her endorsement of Romney today - "probably the best candidate" - is a big deal, it seems to me. McCain is a non-starter. He is as loathed as Clinton in these parts. Giuliani is, in her words, "very, very liberal." One of his sins? He opposed the impeachment of Bill Clinton. That's the new standard. She is the new Republicanism. The sooner people recognize this, the better.


She is the face of what the hard-core Republican Party has become, particularly during the Bush presidency. That is why she holds the position she holds in that movement. That's why Mitt Romney was giddy with glee when her name passed his lips. He knows that her endorsement is valuable precisely because she holds great sway within the party, and she holds great sway because the hard-core party faithful consider her a hero for expressing the thoughts which they themselves believe but which other, less courageous Republican figures are afraid to express.

This is not about a single comment or isolated remark. The more Ann Coulter says these things, the more popular she becomes in this movement. What this is about is that she reflects exactly what sort of political movement this is. She reflects its true impulses and core beliefs. If that were not the case, why would she continue to receive top billing at their most prestigious events, and why would she continue to be lavished with rock star-adoration by the party faithful?
Again, I can't put it better than that if I tried for days. Time and time again, Coulter makes these remarks, and the controversy blows over, and she's invited back to the next big GOP event, explicitly endorsed by the GOP faithful.

###

As with most political controversies, the right has an answer to Coulter's remarks. (Don't all of these things always happen in twos?) In this case, the answer is Bill Maher. Last Friday, on his HBO show, Maher had this to say about Dick Cheney's close call with terrorists in Afghanistan (I watched the show, and these are the words from the transcript on his Website):

But I have zero doubt that if Dick Cheney was not in power, people wouldn’t be dying needlessly tomorrow. No, I’m just saying that if he did die—other people – more people would live. That’s a fact.

As I've written, it was a stupid, dumb thing to say, unequivocally.

Quite naturally, right wingers were quick to jump on Maher's comments, and more importantly, to wildly distort them.

Dr. Michael Alan Weiner, known to the world as Michael Savage, had this to say on his radio show about Maher's comments:

[Maher] called for Cheney's death, OK, and everyone knows that. Apparently it's OK to call for the death of the vice president, but it's not OK to say that you find lesbian marriage disgusting and nauseating and it makes you want to puke. This shows you why liberalism is a mental disorder.

Think Savage is some remote, ignored commentator? Wrong -- his radio show boasts an audience of about eight million listeners a week. (For those of you really curious, Click Here to listen to the audio of Savage's comments.) By the way, who elects to have himself called "Savage"?

And of course, Rush Limbaugh had to get in on the act, too. As Media Matters noted, Limbaugh weighed in on Maher's comments on his radio show (Click Here to listen to the audio):

Well, whatever it is, it is sick, and it resides exclusively on the left. And yet these people get away with this image of love and tolerance and compassion, humanitarianism, and all of this -- when they're just a bunch of sickies. When you read this, you're going to want to throw up. They're actually American citizens hoping for the assassination of the vice president of the United States.

When you go back to the '90s, I mean there was, on our side of the aisle, there was a tremendous amount of disgust with Bill Clinton over any number of things. I don't recall anybody actively wishing, and I don't recall any movies, nor do I recall any books devoted to the subject of assassinating Bill Clinton, or Hillary, or the Vice President Al Gore. It's a new phenomena, and it's not just related to the Florida 2000 imbroglio and the aftermath. There are some sick, sick people out there, and this is all happening, by the way, after they won the election.

Media Matters also notes, from Coulter's book High Crimes and Misdemeanors:

In this recurring nightmare of a presidency, we have a national debate about whether he "did it," even though all sentient people know he did. Otherwise there would be debates only about whether to impeach or assassinate.

This is PR 101 from the Republican playbook - keep repeating a lie or distortion until it's generally accepted as the truth. Anyone remember Al Gore "Inventing the Internet"?

Eh, enough of Coulter, Maher and the rest. There are many more important things to weigh and consider.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

CNN disses Coulter, or is it the opposite?

Yesterday, CNN booked Ann Coulter to appear on Paula Zahn's show at 8 p.m. (The only reason I could ever think of to watch Zahn's show.) The network promoted the appearance in the afternoon, and I decided to TiVo it to see what Coulter had to say.

Of course, Coulter failed to appear, which probably was wise on her part, and the part of CNN. I would love to find out the real story there - did she actually cancel, or did CNN tell her "thanks but no thanks."

I'm already tired of hearing of the coverage about this. Yes, I know - two days ago I was complaining about a lack of coverage on her comment, and today I'm complaining about the huge amount of coverage. But, I didn't think there would be endless debate about it, and there has been.

What I specifically meant by bemoaning the lack of coverage was that it seemed like news organizations were burying the story. The proof is in the pudding - many did. This is news for two reasons: 1. She called John Edwards a "faggot", and 2. Moments before, she was introduced by Mitt Romney. So yes, this is news more than some bigot on the street yelling at two men walking arm-in-arm down the street.

Of course I support Coulter's First Amendment right to be a bigot (the downside of our Constitution, but I'm not for censorship), but this is a woman that Republicans routinely get behind because she has a legion of sheep who follow her and believe her every word. Oh, and she sells lots of books. And she's better looking (arguably) than Rush Limbaugh. So, this is a person who rubs elbows with top Republicans. And that is why her comments are news.

I was happy to see several Republican presidential candidates condemn her remarks.

What annoys me is that the media plays right into her hands - she does this to sell books. And she's probably laughing all the way to the bank.

The best defense against Coulter's screeds are to ignore her. Nothing would devastate her more than irrelevance. As much as I despise her, she's relevant because when she says something, the morons with microphones run up to her and hang on her every word.

I wonder when she'll next be on the Today Show? We've got an election coming up - no way she's on the sidelines, unless she chooses to be. (Could we ever get that lucky?) Hey, there's always Faux News Channel, and there's always room for one more purveyor of hate on that staff.

Almost equally damning were Bill Maher's comments on his HBO show last Friday evening. Bill's a radical liberal who makes me look conservative. I listen to him, but I always take his comments at face value. He can be funny, witty and offensive all in one sentence.

Maher had this to say about Vice President Cheney's brush with terrorism in Afghanistan, when a suicide bomber unsuccessfully tried to drive a car bomb into the military base where he was staying. Cheney came away from the incident unharmed, to the relief of... most. Maher wasn't one of them.

On his show, this is what Maher said:

"I have no doubt that if Dick Cheney was not in power, people wouldn't be dying needlessly tomorrow." (The audience applauds this line). He then went on to say: "I'm just saying if he did die, other people, more people would live, That's a fact." [Emphasis Maher's]

Stupid and inexcusable, without equivocation.

I've said this many times, including to people who have sent me stupid e-mail forwards about the death of President Bush. NOT funny, under any circumstances. As much as I despise Bush and Cheney, jokes like this are not only inappropriate, they are outrageous and if someone is not careful when making them, they're illegal. (And they should be.)

It's high time that Maher and Coulter are treated like the people they are - far left and far right ideologues, respectively, who aren't worthy of our attention.

Although, I don't put Maher in the same category as Coulter, offensive as his remark about Cheney was.

If you look back on the history of what Coulter has said, her reputation is far worse. But, in the end, who cares? As if a scorecard of Maher vs. Coulter would accomplish anything. But, Coulter's comments about the 9-11 widows enshrines her in the Hate Hall of Fame, if there is one, somewhere. (Far, faaaarrrrr south, maybe?)

I will add one other thought, though. If I had come up with a reason as to why Coulter seems to be getting most of the negative press between the two, I'd say it's because she used an offensive term against a whole group of people; millions of people, in fact.

One more thought - is it obvious to anyone else that homosexuals are the last major group that it's socially acceptable (in some circles, that is, to the right of center) to discriminate against? The Republican Party has and is doing all it can to deny homosexuals the rights they deserve - civil unions my ass. They deserve the right to marry just as heterosexuals do. Period.

Can you imagine how much worse this outcry would have been had Coulter gotten up on stage and called Barack Obama a "nigger"? Um, she may not have gotten out of D.C. alive. Or, what if she called Joe Lieberman a "kike"? Both of those scenarios would have resulted in Coulter being much more ostracized than she is now. And rightfully so. (And can anyone honestly believe she wouldn't utter such remarks? Really, it's only a matter of time with this bigot. Okay, wait - Lieberman supports the War in Iraq - he's safe.)

But, she deserves much more scorn than she's getting for using a hate word toward someone she disagrees with politically. Censorship? No. Ridicule? I'll take two orders, with a side of laughter that people even pay attention to her at all.

How about we just all ignore her?

Fat chance.

Labels: , , , , , ,