Fighting the War on Error

"You measure a democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists."
- Political & Social Activist Abbie Hoffman (1936-1989)

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Oliver Stone taking on another president

This week's Entertainment Weekly has a very interesting piece about Oliver Stone's upcoming movie, W, starring Josh Brolin as President Bush and Elizabeth Banks as Laura Bush. It's probably no big surprise that he's having trouble finding a Dick that's worthy of bringing Cheney to life. Too bad the late Rodney Dangerfield isn't available. I'm wondering if he's considered Louie Anderson? Wayne Knight? (Of Newman fame in Seinfeld) I think I need to get these suggestions to Stone ASAP.

Stone's movies on presidents have generated plenty of controversy in the past, and this one promises to be the most sensational one of all, without question.

To begin with, Stone says in the EW piece that the film "could be ready" before the election. Who's he think he's kidding? There's no question, barring a major setback, that the film will be ready before Nov. 3. It doesn't take a studio executive to figure out that the film is going to have a whole lot more appeal before the election than it will after it. Strictly from a financial standpoint, it's not a bold prediction that it will in theaters before Halloween.

I've always been a very big fan of Stone's - from Scarface to Platoon and Nixon, he hasn't made many movies I haven't liked, save JFK. In fact, Nixon is one of my favorite political movies ever. Here's the trailer...


The film is superbly cast - Anthony Hopkins as President Nixon, Paul Sorvino as Henry Kissinger, Powers Boothe as Alexander Haig and James Woods as H.R. Haldeman. Anyway, check it out - it's that good, if you're a political junkie.

Anyway, back to W. ...

Many are already accusing Stone of playing politics by filming the movie this year, and he's already taking a combative tone about it:
...not a single major studio wanted anything to do with W. "When push comes to shove, all these media companies are chickens---," Stone says. "They're all part of conglomerates."
As far as Stone making this movie this year to somehow influence the election, I hope he disagrees with that contention half as much as I do. After all, Bush isn't running for re-election - John McSame is running for his third term. Anyway, I think voters are smarter than that. And even if Stone admits that he is intentionally making the film this year, it would be no worse than Sinclair Broadcasting Group's decision in the fall of 2004 to run the anti-John Kerry documentary Stolen Honor: John Kerry's Record of Betrayal, which was a totally transparent attempt to smear and slander Kerry just two weeks before the election.

In the interview, Stone give more insight into why he's making the movie:
"Bush may turn out to be the worst president in history," he declares as he peeks into room after room [looking at a possible shooting location for the film]. "I think history is going to be very tough on him. But that doesn't mean he isn't a great story. It's almost Capra-esque, the story of a guy who had very limited talents in life, except for the ability to sell himself. The fact that he had to overcome the shadow of his father and the weight of his family name — you have to admire his tenacity. There's almost an Andy Griffith quality to him, from A Face in the Crowd. If Fitzgerald were alive today, he might be writing about him. He's sort of a reverse Gatsby."
Honestly, it sounds as if the movie could almost be a comedy in some ways, if there weren't such life and death decisions made by this administration. To wit:
In one Strangelove-like moment, [Bush] tries to sell Tony Blair on the idea of provoking war with Iraq by flying a U.S. plane painted with U.N. colors over Baghdad, baiting Saddam to shoot it down. "Plan B is assassinate the sonofabitch," Bush informs the horrified prime minister.
I've read words to this effect in other books about Bush, most notably Bob Woodward's third book on Bush's presidency, State of Denial: Bush at War, Part III, so it's not completely out of the question.

Fortunately, it doesn't sound like the whole movie is going to be dark and serious. I mean, it's President Bush (at right, depicted by Brolin) we're talking about here. A sample of the film's lighter poignant and shocking moments from the script:
Oedipal Wreck After his father is elected president, Bush tells Laura, "I'll never get out of Poppy's shadow.... I wish he'd LOST.... No matter what I do, it's never going to be good enough."

Tough Talker Bush, 26, drunk-drives his car onto the lawn of his parents' D.C. home, and challenges his dad to a fight, "Let's go mano a mano! Right here. Right now!" Then, in 2003, when France fails to back the U.S. on its invasion of Iraq, Bush says of French president Jacques Chirac, "I'd like to stuff a plate of freedom fries down that slick piece of s---'s throat."

Practical Joker During a prep meeting on Iraq, Bush playfully locks Colin Powell out of the room. He then steals a mint from Condoleezza Rice and tells Paul Wolfowitz to trim his ear hair.

Man of Faith In 1999, Bush confesses to a televangelist, "The truth is, I really don't want to run [for president].... But I feel that God wants me to do this, and I must do it. I MUST."

Brother in Arms In a 2003 sit-down with Saudi ambassador Prince Bandar, Bush explains that he has given up sweets since the beginning of the Iraq war. "This is my personal sacrifice to show support for our troops," he says.
That last one's a doozy, and no doubt a comfort to the Americans who are strung out from the stress of combat, many of them Stop-Lossed or given extended tours of duty. Seems like an equitable equation to me - the man who sent soldiers off to die has given up sweets.

Like Bush, the movie sounds tragic, funny, dark, complicated and at times downright silly. Since Nixon and JFK were worlds apart as far as reception, it's tough to predict how W will be received, but one thing's for sure - there will be lots of press and controversy. And I'm looking forward to all of it.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, November 11, 2006

Bill Mahr, censored!



So, it seems that a giant media conglomerate has struck again. Bill Mahr, on Larry King Live on Wednesday night (above), made the assertion that many people in high leadership positions in the Republican Party are gay, and he named Ken Mehlman, the current head of the RNC.

In the subsequent rebroadcast of Larry King at midnight, Mahr's naming of Mehlman was edited out of the broadcast.

I just finished watching last night's episode of Bill Mahr's show, Real Time with Bill Mahr, and no mention of gay Republicans.

Before I go any further, and this will come as no surprise to any regular readers of this blog, I don't care if any or all of the leaders of the Republican Party are gay. I really don't. The only issue I would have with it is their fervent anti-gay stance on just about every social issue, including gay marriage, which they want to amend the Constitution to make illegal in all states.

The issue this raises to me is media conglomeration, and how an increasingly consolidated media controls what we hear. In essence, with some exceptions, we only hear what these media giants, and the politicians who benefit from their campaign largess, want us to hear. That ought to frighten every American.

I'll bet everything I'm worth that one or more of the following happened:

1. An attorney representing Ken Mehlman and/or the RNC made a phone call to Time Warner with these threats: a lawsuit; and worse for Time/Warner, the threat that no prominent Republicans would appear or give interviews on CNN, HBO, Time Magazine, etc. Time/Warner owns all three (and a whole lot more).

2. Bill Mahr was told to shut his mouth, which he did on his show last night. No prominent Republicans announced.

Okay, I freely admit that it was stupid of Mahr to even allude to the fact that he was going to out Mehlman, which he ended up doing on Larry King anyway. It's unwise, and he's better have proof, or there would have been a lawsuit, a point I'm sure Time/Warner's lawyers no doubt made to Mahr in fairly animated terms.

But, is it right that a phone call from the RNC or a lawyer can effectively shut someone up? In this case, probably, because Mahr was out of line, IF it's untrue. But, what if Mahr has rock solid proof? The threat of a lawsuit has censored him. That's not good for our democracy.

Neither is media conglomeration, which has taken place at a breathtaking pace under this administration. A Republican-controlled Congress relaxed regulations a few years ago that allowed companies to purchase and own more radio and television stations.

The example above is just one way that this rapid consolidation of ownership can come back and bit democracy in the ass.

Anyone remember the 2004 election-year media censorship? In 2004, The Sinclair Broadcast Group caused a huge controversy when it forbade eight of its ABC-affiliate stations from broadcasting an April 30 episode of a Nightline that was to pay tribute to the 721 soldiers killed by reading their names on the air. The reasons given? That it undermined the war effort. A little investigation uncovered the fact that all of the senior leaders at Sinclair were maxed out contributors to the Bush campaign.

But, Sinclair wasn't done. In October 2004, Jon Lieberman, a Sinclair executive, revealed in an interview with the Baltimore Sun that Sinclair planned to order all 62 (Yes, 62!!!) of its ABC affiliates to air Stolen Honor: Wounds That Never Heal, a documentary critical of Democratic Presidential Nominee John Kerry's anti-Vietnam War activism just two weeks prior to the presidential election. Public outrage followed, and Sinclair aired an edited version, and they fired Lieberman for revealing company business.

If our government prevents something from being broadcast, it's called prior restraint. But, what do you call it if a large media conglomerate friendly with the party in power forbids unflattering material to that party from being aired? Second-degree prior restraint? A threat to a free press and our very democracy is more like it.

I'm very hopeful that the new Democratic-Congress will immediately repeal the relaxed restrictions on media ownership and put in place more sensible restrictions; restrictions that don't put too much power in the hands of enormous media companies, their executives and their stockholders.

Our democracy, and our free press, depend on it. I'll be writing much more about this in the coming weeks and months, including what we can do about it.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,