Fighting the War on Error

"You measure a democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists."
- Political & Social Activist Abbie Hoffman (1936-1989)

Friday, May 18, 2007

Rumsfeld to teach public policy?

This has got to be the most tragically funny news I've seen in a long time.

It appears that former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld has decided that he wants to teach public policy to graduate and post-graduate students.

That's akin to Don Imus teaching a cultural sensitivity course. Beyond ridiculous.

In my mind, it's no stretch at all to call Rumsfeld the biggest war criminal this country has seen since Lt. William Calley of My Lai fame or former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger.

In today's Washington Times:
"He's considering a lot of things but he wants to remain engaged in public policy issues and is in the process of creating a foundation that would involve teaching and research fellowships for graduate and post-graduate students," Mr. Di Rita [a Rumsfeld aide] said.

The goal is to promote continued U.S. engagement in world affairs in furtherance of U.S. security interests, Mr. Di Rita said.
It's hard to believe that someone like Rumsfeld, for all of the death and destruction he's caused, to be in this much denial. My only question is, when people are this delusional, do they know it, or are they not even aware of how divorced from reality they really are?

Think Progress has some brilliant suggestions on what Rummy could teach his pupes.

I'm just imagining Professor Rumsfeld imparting his wisdom on his young charges. He should start a PR class, How to have the worst press relations ever in 10 easy steps:

1. How to ask and answer your own question, to the annoyance of millions. "Do I wish we had used more troops in Iraq? Yes! Do I have any credibility left with anyone in the free world because of my arrogance and obfuscations during my tenure as secretary of defense? No." [His habit of asking and answering his own questions is one of the most annoying traits I've ever heard in a civil servant - Richard Nixon's habitual references to himself in the third person rate a close second.]

2. When reporters ask you tough questions, just act like you know more than they do, and that it's complicated. One of my favorite examples of this is during his last press conference as defense secretary, a week or two before the election last fall. At a press, he became reeeeally annoyed with the line of questioning, so at one point, he admonished his questioners to "BACK OFF."

3. Be overly vague when the going gets tough. I'll never forget the press conference when he muttered "stuff happens" while Baghdad was being looted during the mayhem after President Bush declared "major combat operations are over."

4. If all else fails, just be vehement. No one mastered this better than Rummy. Even when he was lying (and that was pretty often), he would just act so emphatic to just try and scare some reporters into thinking he MUST be right. Wrong.

I could fill out the rest of the top ten, but you probably get the point.

Donald Rumsfeld... teaching public policy. As the saying goes, if a man lives long enough, he gets to see everything.

Photos from AP via HuffPo

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

To clarify: Abu Ghraib & My Lai

My dad sent me an e-mail tonight about my post yesterday, and he rightly made the point that My Lai and Abu Ghraib are two totally different animals that aren't even in the same ballpark.

He's right.

However, I don't think I adequately explained what I meant.

My Lai and Abu Ghraib aren't comparable on just about every level, without question.

At My Lai, innocent Vietnamese villagers were slaughtered by American soldiers, including women and children. (The actual number who were murdered is disputed - I've read just over 100 in some articles, nearly 350 in another, and 504 on Wikipedia's Website. Wikipedia is an openly edited site, so anything you read on that site should be verified by reputable sources.) Even on the low end, My Lai was a tragedy with few equals in American history.

Abu Ghraib didn't involved hundreds of people dying, but it was a severe abuse of authority, and a severe breach of morality on the part of American soldiers.

The only parallel I was attempting to draw between Abu Ghraib and My Lai was the impact those two events had in the context of the two wars when they occurred. No more, no less.

From a human life perspective, comparing these two tragedies would be like comparing a firecracker to a hydrogen bomb.

I've had a lifelong love affair with similes and metaphors, but sometimes I guess the comparison isn't always successful or obvious.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, February 20, 2007

Teddy: We've lost the moral authority

In less than 48 hours, the documentary film Ghosts of Abu Ghraib premieres on HBO. The film is directed by Rory Kennedy, the youngest child of Senator Robert F. Kennedy and Ethel Kennedy. By most accounts that I've read ahead of time, the film packs a pretty powerful punch, and how could it not, considering the subject matter?

In a column today on Arianna Huffington's Website, Massachusetts Senator Ted Kennedy has a point when he says that "It may well be the steepest and deepest fall from grace in our history."

"Yet at every opportunity, the Administration has tried to minimize the problem and avoid responsibility for it," he wrote.

Like Teddy or hate him, how can a logical person who has even passively followed the Abu Ghraib fiasco disagree, regardless of political persuasion? The most frightening part of the abuse and torture tragedy is that there are Americans who feel that nothing wrong occurred at the prison. Count Rush Limbaugh among them, who infamously said that all he saw in the photographs were "soldiers having a good time." Sick, demented, sad and preposterous.

Quick aside about Ted Kennedy, by the way. Can Republicans possibly be any more trite than bringing up Chappaquiddick every five minutes? Probably my favorite Republican bumper sticker of all time reads, Ted Kennedy's car has killed more people than my guns. My reply to that bumper sticker would be this: George Bush's Iraq War has killed more Americans than 3,000 of Ted Kennedy's cars. No question Kennedy got off easy and that Mary Jo Kopechne's death was tragic, but to hear some people tell it, he killed her in cold blood and walked away scott free. Politics aside, does anyone really believe that? Teddy's got a lot of warts, most self-inflicted, and that scandal tops the list, but he's done a lot of good for our country, too. Oh yea, and can we all agree that he and his members of his have made some pretty tragic sacrifices because they wanted to serve their country? Okay, Kennedy rant over.

Kennedy's right - the images are still disturbing to look at. I remember the shock, horror and disbelief I felt when I first saw the images.

In my lifetime, since I've been old enough to remember and follow politics, I can't think of any single event (Aside from the current War in Iraq itself) that has damaged our credibility and moral standing with the rest of the world more than Abu Ghraib.

I'll rephrase - Abu Ghraib is my generation's My Lai. Okay, that might be overstating the case a bit - over 100 innocent Vietnamese were killed in that tragedy. I'm not suggesting that Abu Ghraib is equal, I'm merely suggesting that its impact is equal.

We are America - we are supposed to stand for Democracy, freedom, peace and human rights. This war has put all four of those into doubt, and Abu Ghraib only exacerbated our free fall as the moral authority in the free world.

Adding to many Americans' frustration is the lack of any sort of in-depth, independent investigation of the scandal. In the days following Abu Ghraib going public, the Bush Administration seemed more intent at castigating those who exposed the scandal than getting to the bottom of what happened. And I won't even recap the absurdity of former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld's comments.

Kennedy writes:

What we got instead were nine incomplete and self-serving internal investigations by the Pentagon. None of the investigators were given the authority to challenge the conduct of the civilian command. The report of the Schlesinger Panel found that abuses were "widespread" and that there was "both institutional and personal responsibility at higher levels." But Secretary Rumsfeld refused to let the panel to consider personal accountability for the abuses.

The Republican rubber-stamp Congress was complicit in the Administration's efforts to evade responsibility.

I know that the DemocratIC Congress has better things to do right now, like determining whether to fund President Bush's troop escalation, but once time permits, I certainly hope Congress initiates a bona fide investigation into Abu Ghraib, one with teeth and subpoena power.

Don't forget to check out Ghosts of Abu Ghraib, which premieres this Thursday night on HBO at 9:30 p.m. ET/PT.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

I'm back! First, a must-see movie



Last night, I saw a promo on HBO for Ghosts of Abu Ghraib, and it looks shocking, eye opening and haunting. It's directed by Robert F. Kennedy's youngest daughter, Rory Kennedy (interviewed above). It looks to be another must-see movie about the U.S. war machine, but this time it's about one of the most sickening displays of what a few rogues in the U.S. military can accomplish.

With a nod to the Haditha Massacre, has anything damaged our credibility abroad this much since My Lai?

I know I won't miss this - it premieres on HBO on Thursday, February 22. You probably have HBO for the great exclusive shows like the Sopranos. Here's another reason to have at least one pay channel, if you are trying to decide on one. The network also ran an excellent documentary called Hacking Democracy last fall, and you'll be hearing a whole lot more about that from me in the coming weeks -- by that I mean the movie and the movement to have a paper trail when we vote. My voice is going to be heard loud and wide on this topic (I hope).

Anyway, check out Ghosts of Abu Ghraib - it's certainly worth an hour and a half. Since the director, Rory Kennedy, is a Kennedy, I wonder how the right wing will attack her?

Like the promo said last night -- "because there is no such thing as 'a little' torture."

Labels: , , , ,